Metropolitan Museum of Art

Art museum on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan. It turns up in the reading as a test of taste: a Chris Creed blog post finds flawed art on its walls, and in Aoibheann Sweeney’s novel Miranda fails to love its marble statues.

At a glance

SourceAuthorRoleIn one line
A blog for people who make stuff for a livingChris CreedsettingAn overheard critique here leads to the post’s point that art doesn’t have to be right.
Among Other Things, I’ve Taken Up SmokingAoibheann SweeneysettingMiranda visits the museum her father mentioned and finds its classical statues a test she cannot pass.

📍 OpenStreetMap · Google Maps

A blog for people who make stuff for a living — Chris Creed (2015)

Source: Original · Readwise highlight

We were walking around The Met this weekend and overheard a woman critiquing a piece of art.

  • Role: setting
  • In the article: Walking through the Met, the author overhears a woman criticising a painting’s perspective and proportions, and reflects that imperfect work hangs in the country’s largest art museum.
  • Why it matters: The museum’s prestige makes the point: flawed art is still on its walls.

Among Other Things, I’ve Taken Up Smoking — Aoibheann Sweeney (2007)

Source: Original

The Metropolitan Museum of Art was set off from Fifth Avenue by a wide set of marble steps, fountains on one side and Central Park spread out like a garden behind it, as far as the eye could see.

  • Role: setting
  • In the book: Alone in the city, Miranda takes the subway to “the one museum my father had mentioned”. She passes the Egyptian tomb and cases of bowls into a gallery of ancient marble statues, “impossibly ancient and perfect but somehow enervating”, and feels it as “a test”: “My father, I knew, would be disappointed that I did not like it more.” She leaves for Central Park and thinks, “Maybe I just don’t like cities.”
  • Why it matters: The Met stands in for her classicist father’s world; failing to love it is Miranda’s first quiet break from his tastes. Its grandeur, and the classical sculpture in particular, is what makes the scene work.